Employee Retention Tax Eligibility Conundrum: Understanding the Pitfalls

Richard Krause
Jan 26
4 min read

Updated: Apr 19

In 2020, when the pandemic hit, businesses across the country were facing unprecedented challenges. To help weather the storm, the U.S. government introduced the Employee Retention Credit (ERC), designed to incentivize employers to keep employees on their payroll despite economic setbacks. For many, the ERC was a lifeline—a much-needed financial cushion to survive during turbulent times.

However, as businesses scrambled to apply for the credit and navigate the complexities of the IRS guidelines, a wave of confusion and errors followed. Employees, tax preparers, and business owners alike began facing eligibility hurdles, mistakes, and overlooked opportunities. The Employee Retention Tax Eligibility Conundrum began.

The Confusion Around Eligibility

While the ERC was introduced as a relief measure, its eligibility criteria were far from simple. The credit was available to employers who had either a significant drop in revenue or had been fully or partially shut down due to government orders. These parameters seemed straightforward, but things quickly became muddled. What exactly constitutes a “significant drop” in revenue? What qualifies as a “full” or “partial” shutdown? What documentation is required to prove eligibility?

Business owners, particularly those with limited tax expertise, often struggled to navigate these questions, leading to confusion and, in some cases, incorrect filings. Tax preparers were faced with the daunting task of ensuring their clients met all eligibility requirements, often working under tight deadlines. The result? Many businesses missed out on claiming the ERC they were entitled to, while others ended up filing incorrectly, leading to penalties and audit risks.

Common Pitfalls in the ERC Process

Misunderstanding Revenue Decline Criteria
One of the most common issues arose from a misunderstanding of what constituted a “substantial decline” in gross receipts. Some businesses miscalculated their eligibility due to unclear revenue comparisons and reporting mistakes. The IRS set specific thresholds based on quarter-over-quarter revenue losses, but many businesses misunderstood how to apply these rules, potentially leaving money on the table or making an incorrect claim.
Not Considering All Eligible Quarters
The ERC wasn’t just for one quarter—it covered multiple quarters, depending on when the business was impacted. Many businesses overlooked the eligibility for quarters they hadn’t initially considered, or assumed they were only eligible for one quarter, missing out on additional relief they were entitled to.
Misinterpretation of Government Orders
To qualify for the ERC under a shutdown provision, businesses had to prove they were fully or partially shut down due to government orders. The issue arose when businesses assumed they qualified without fully understanding the criteria. Some business owners mistakenly believed they were fully shut down based on local restrictions, without realizing that specific language in the IRS guidelines required more detailed documentation.
Incorrect Payroll Calculations
Determining the correct amount of qualified wages that could be claimed for the credit was another area of confusion. Employers often failed to include the right wages, such as wages paid to part-time employees or health plan expenses, or they mistakenly included ineligible wages, leading to overclaims.
Failure to Review Past Filings
Many businesses filed their claims without fully reviewing their past tax returns or payroll documentation. They didn’t check for accuracy, which later led to discrepancies. Over time, these small errors accumulated, potentially jeopardizing the credit they had already claimed or missed opportunities to receive more money.

The Road to Rectification

It’s easy to see how such confusion led to mistakes, and it’s clear that the IRS guidelines for the ERC could have been clearer from the start. However, all is not lost for businesses that may have miscalculated their eligibility or missed filing deadlines. The IRS allows businesses to amend their previous tax returns and adjust their claims for ERC benefits, but the process can be complicated and time-consuming.

This is where erctaxcrisis.com, a dedicated initiative by TaxpayersVoice.com, come in. Their team specializes in reviewing past filings and helping businesses claim what’s rightfully owed to them. With over 25 years of experience, they are experts at navigating the maze of ERC eligibility, ensuring that businesses receive the full benefits they deserve without falling victim to common pitfalls.

Schedule Online Consultation

Book Now

How to Avoid the Pitfalls

If you're a business owner or tax preparer concerned about your ERC eligibility, here are a few steps to ensure you're on the right track:

Review IRS Guidelines Carefully – Understand the full scope of eligibility criteria and keep track of the most recent IRS updates.
Consult with Experts – Work with tax professionals who specialize in ERC claims and can help clarify any confusion.
Double-Check Your Documents – Ensure that all relevant payroll and revenue documents are accurate and align with IRS guidelines.
Amend Incorrect Filings – If you've already filed but suspect mistakes, consider working with a tax advisor to amend your returns and claim any missed credits.
Stay Proactive – Don't wait for an IRS audit. Be proactive in reviewing your filings and addressing potential errors before they become larger issues.

Conclusion

The Employee Retention Credit has proven to be an invaluable financial lifeline for businesses, but the complexity surrounding its eligibility has led many into a conundrum. With clear guidance, expert support, and a commitment to accuracy, businesses can navigate these pitfalls and secure the relief they deserve. The ERC is not just about getting a refund—it’s about ensuring that businesses, employees, and tax preparers get what they’re owed, empowering them to continue thriving in uncertain times.

If you're unsure about your eligibility, or if you think you may have missed out on claiming your ERC, consider seeking professional help—after all, every dollar counts.